8.08.2007

Ohio Educators Misunderstand Continuous Improvement

When recognition grows for a concept like continuous improvement, it is perhaps inevitable that the terminology will be more widely used – and misused. I recently saw a striking example of this.


            I had already noticed a trend of increasing use of the phrase “continuous improvement” in the field of education. In one sense, that is understandable. You could argue that educators are in the business of continually improving their students – or that continuous improvement is what education is all about. I am sure many educators see themselves this way.


            However, the Ohio Department of Education has found a way to completely misuse the term. I discovered this in recent news reports about the Cleveland school district, which has struggled in recent years to meet state standards for education.


            The latest reports were good news for Cleveland. Performance of the district’s students has improved. As a result, the state education department removed the district from the category of “academic watch.” Now Cleveland has been moved up to the classification of “continuous improvement.”


            Excuse me?


            Continuous improvement is a way of operating. It is an approach and, more importantly, a philosophy – the idea that you can always make things better. It is not a grade or a ranking or a category or a classification. Not only is Ohio’s use of the term incorrect, it is also confusing. I don’t know what their classification means.


            I am a journalist by background, so I tend to focus on word usage perhaps more than most people. However, this is not just about word usage. When the terminology surrounding an important concept is misused, it creates misunderstandings about that concept, which can damage or undermine efforts to promote valuable ideas.


            It is a shame that this has happened. Someone needs to educate the state educators.


 

8.06.2007

How Renting a Car Could be Easier

Lean disciples know that, in addition to eliminating unnecessary process steps, it is also important to create the right sequence of value-adding steps. Having the right steps in the wrong order can be just as bad as including wrong steps.


            I was reminded of this during my recent vacation when, on two separate occasions, I rented cars.


            Reserving a car online is a fairly simple, straightforward process, which can be completed through almost any travel website. You specify when and where you will pick up and drop off the vehicle, and you indicate what type of vehicle you want (i.e., mid-size car, full-size SUV, etc.).


            But when you actually pick up the car, you are asked additional questions. Do you accept or decline insurance from the rental company? Will you return the car with a full tank, or pay the rental company to fill it?


            Why can’t those questions also be asked online, at the start of the process? It would save time at the airport. (And believe me, after a long flight, every minute you spend standing at the rental counter, waiting to get started on your actual vacation, is frustrating. It’s even worse when you encounter a rental agent with a bad attitude, but don’t get me started on that.)


            The car-rental companies have done a pretty good job of making the return of a vehicle a fast, painless process. (You drive in, an agent with a handheld device walks up to you, looks at the car, asks a few questions and prints out your receipt.) The same is not true when it comes to picking up the car.


            Does anyone else feel the same way?


 

8.03.2007

Improving Flow at Pearl Harbor, Part Two

The Visitor Center at Pearl Harbor serves more than one purpose. First, it is a jumping-off point for the memorials at the U.S.S. Arizona, the U.S.S. Missouri and the U.S.S. Bowfin.


            It is also a gathering place, where on any given day a WWII veteran or other VIP might be on hand to answer questions and sign autographs. The gift shop is in the center, so you can purchase Pearl Harbor memorabilia.


            But the center is also an exhibit in its own right, with educational displays throughout the interior as well as on the exterior grounds. And that is where you run into a problem.


            The center consists primarily of a large central area surrounded by walls on most sides. (Like so many public areas in Hawaii, including restaurants and hotel lobbies, the center is partially open to the outside.) There are some enclosed rooms off to the sides, including the theater, the gift shop and rest rooms.


            A great many people who visit take the time to look at the wall and exterior displays, which are numbered and feature photographs and text. Many visitors rent equipment to listen to a self-guided audio tour, which – using the numbers – walks you from one display to the next, first inside, then outside.


            The problem is, aside from putting the displays in numerical order, the people who set them up failed to adequately address the issue of flow.


            First, Pearl Harbor consistently attracts large crowds, so at any given time you may have dozens of people gathered near each display.


            Second, the physical layout makes no distinction between those listening to the audio tour and those who are not. So people on the audio tour, steadily progressing from one exhibit to the next, are in the same area as people not on the tour, who may or may not be following the exhibits in order. Gridlock often results. (And in a building without air conditioning, open to Hawaii’s warm, humid weather, this is not a good thing.)


            In a visit to Pearl Harbor last month, I did not attempt the audio tour. My wife and daughter did, but after encountering the crowds, they both chose to sit outside and simply listen to the recordings. My son-in-law stuck with the audio tour, but expressed disappointment at the end that he was unable to see many of the exhibits because of the crush of visitors.


             A fund-raising effort is under way to expand the facilities at the center. But after viewing plans for the expansion, I concluded that it does nothing to address the flow problems.


            The first thought that occurs to me is that it might make sense to reconfigure the displays with two ways to view them – one would be a path for those on the audio tour, with some other arrangement for everyone else. (In lean terms, think of the two groups of people as different families of products, going through different manufacturing cells.) That might involve making the displays free-standing, rather than having them hang on the wall, so that people could view them from two sides.


            I’m sure there are additional approaches that might help. If you have any suggestions, please post your comments below.


            Most people have limited interest in history. But there is huge interest in the displays at Pearl Harbor, which represent a great opportunity for adults to brush up on their history and teach it to their children as well. It’s a shame that opportunity is being squandered by poor flow that interferes with the public’s ability to view the displays.


 

8.01.2007

Improving Flow at Pearl Harbor, Part One

I spent most of the past two weeks not thinking about lean or anything work-related, while I enjoyed a wonderful vacation with family in Hawaii.


            However, there were a few moments during our trip when the lean part of me came to the forefront. Some of these occurred during our visit to Pearl Harbor.


            The memorials there are an extremely popular tourist attraction, which, unfortunately, is troubled by some significant flow problems. This post and the next one will be devoted to discussions of those problems.


            Most people who come to Pearl Harbor want to visit the memorial at the U.S.S. Arizona. This memorial is a simply-designed white structure built like an island in the middle of the bay, directly above the spot where the Arizona, sunk by the Japanese attack on Dec. 7, 1941, still lies beneath the waves. The ship is a tomb for the sailors who died on board during the attack, and their names are engraved inside the structure. Visiting the memorial is a moving experience, and well worth the trip.


            (The Arizona is not the only memorial at Pearl Harbor. You can also climb aboard the U.S.S. Missouri, the battleship aboard which Japanese leaders formally surrendered at the end of the war. And you can climb down into the U.S.S. Bowfin submarine. But neither of those attracts the number of people who flock to the Arizona memorial.)


            To visit the Arizona, you first obtain a ticket for a particular time. At that time, you enter a theater within the visitor center, located on shore. After viewing a 20-minute video about the attack on Pearl Harbor and the war with Japan, you walk to a pier, board a ferry and sail to the memorial. After you disembark for your visit, the group that preceded yours boards the ferry for their return trip to shore.


            That system seems to work reasonably well. The problem occurs at the start of the process when you get your ticket, which is free.


            The travel books I read in advance of our trip warned me about the high demand for tickets and the need to arrive early – so my family and I got to the visitor center at around 8:30 a.m., about an hour after the ticket office opened.


When we arrived, we saw a line at the ticket office that snaked out the front door of the center and all the way around the front grounds. I would estimate there were at least 200 people standing in line, and probably more – a scene, I am told, that is repeated almost every day. After spending at least 40 minutes in line, we got tickets for 10:30 a.m. I understand that distribution of tickets ends each day by early afternoon, once capacity has been exhausted. As far as I know, tickets cannot be obtained in advance.


The lean part of my brain was yelling at me: It shouldn’t have to be like this! There must be a way to apply lean principles and improve the flow!


Any suggestions?


 

7.30.2007

A Year of Cost Control: Wrongheaded Business Analysis

            A commentary by an executive of consulting firm Accenture about the wireless telephone service industry embodies a lot of things that are wrong with the way some people view business.


            Stephen Gardiner, an Accenture senior executive, has a piece posted on the company’s Web site that notes the rapid growth of the telco industry is slowing. He observes that


 


            Our research in this area has discovered that global wireless operators with an average annual Operating Expenditure) of $24 billion will need to save 4% in total operating expenses, or a staggering $700 million per year, in order to recover their cost of capital.


 


            Gardiner suggests that 2007 may be “the year of cost control.”


 


            I find that disturbing. It seems to be based on the idea that industries go through cycles. Rapid growth occurs early on, and when that slows, businesses finally get around to managing properly so that they can be profitable in bad times as well as good.


            Gardiner adds,


 


Is 2007 the year of cost control? My answer is not a simple yes or no…

The Telco industry is maturing at different paces. Northern Europe is already thinking about cost reduction and I think the U.S. will be next. Asia has had success in growing new products and services so their focus will remain on delivery for the time being while Southern Europe
is still very much in a growth phase.

Cost savings will continue to be a hot topic for Telecom Operators for some time to come. You only have to look at other more mature industries for insights on how big an issue it will be.


 


            Would a lean company think that way? Do you believe that, at any time during the past 50 years, executives at Toyota ever declared a particular year to be a year of cost control? I doubt it.


 


            I’m also amused by Gardiner’s description of how Accenture advises clients to control costs:



Reducing costs should be viewed in a holistic manner, considering the entire enterprise as opposed to just one function. We conceived our framework for cost analysis and modeling after our research suggested that combining top-down targeting with bottom-up transformational diagnostics can help to lead to sustainable cost leadership. I'd also recommend looking at less traditional areas, such as channel optimization and routing, product and offer simplification, and business intelligence.


 


            While I’m all in favor of viewing costs (and all other business issues) in a “holistic manner,” this paragraph sounds to me like business mumbo-jumbo. More importantly, it treats cost control as something to be undertaken at a particular time, rather than something that should be embedded into a company’s DNA – as one part of a lean strategy.


 


            By the way, Accenture does have a few articles on their site specifically about lean and six sigma. But my impression is they don’t really get it.


 


            Accenture is large, successful consulting firm. It’s a shame they are stuck in old ways of viewing business.


 

7.11.2007

Time Out

I'll be on vacation until the week of July 30. If my desire to blog becomes overwhelming while I devote the next couple of weeks to self-indulgent leisure time, I may come online before then. However, if I gain sufficient satisfaction from sun, sand, food, drink and family, the blog will be quiet for a while. See you later!


 

7.09.2007

Toyota Shifting Production to Lower Labor Costs? It Could Happen

Would Toyota, the embodiment of lean manufacturing and respect for people, ever consider relocating production to reduce labor costs?


            According to recent reports, that’s exactly what Toyota is considering.


            It wouldn’t be a case of shifting production from America to Asia. Rather, Toyota may pull production of the Tacoma out of the NUMMI plant in Fremont, California, and shift it to somewhere else in North America.


            NUMMI (New United Motor Manufacturing Inc.) is a partnership of Toyota and General Motors, formed in 1984. The Fremont plant is the only Toyota plant using UAW labor and one of the highest-labor-cost facilities in the entire American automotive industry.


            One report, in the San Jose Mercury-News, notes that


            NUMMI management stopped short of saying in a statement that it would move Tacoma truck production. It also did not say it would lay off any workers, or consider shutting down the plant. But it stressed that NUMMI must 'improve its competitiveness.'


'The industry's going through a very tough time and many plants have or are scheduled to close,' NUMMI spokesman Lance Tomasu said in a prepared statement. 'NUMMI will only retain its business if it is able to improve its competitiveness.'


The statement added that pressure to compete is felt more intensely at NUMMI than other auto manufacturing plants 'because of California's challenging business environment.' It said NUMMI's labor costs are higher than both the automotive industry average and U.S. manufacturing average, that raw material costs are rising, and that NUMMI's location is far from the majority of its suppliers.


            The Fremont facility also makes the Toyota Corolla and the Pontiac Vibe. But the Tacoma represents 40 percent of the plant’s total output, which was 428,000 vehicles last year.


 


            The current UAW contract at NUMMI expires in August 2009, and a no-layoff clause prevents workforce reductions. So unless the UAW is prepared to make concessions, moving production may be the most attractive alternative.


 


            Do you think this prospect is at odds with Toyota’s commitment to lean and respect for people? Post your comments below.


 


 


           

7.06.2007

Easing Airline Delays: What Can Lean Do?

Can a lean approach help address the delays and inconvenience that increasingly plague the nation’s airlines?


            As I read about how bad things are, I can’t help but believe the answer is yes. The problems facing the airlines involve issues of variation and capacity, both of which are frequent targets of lean initiatives.


            Two recent articles in The New York Times prompt these thoughts. One focuses on how bad delays really are – and the answer is, worse than statistics indicate. According to the article by Jeff Bailey and Nate Schweber,


            …statistics track how late airplanes are, not how late passengers are. The longest delays — those resulting from missed connections and canceled flights — involve sitting around for hours or even days in airports and hotels and do not officially get counted. Researchers and consumer advocates have taken notice and urged more accurate reporting.


Researchers at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology did a study several years ago and found that when missed connections and flight cancellations are factored in, the average wait was two-thirds longer than the official statistic. They also determined that as planes become more crowded — and jets have never been as jammed as they are today — the delays grow much longer because it becomes harder to find a seat on a later flight.


That finding prompted the M.I.T. researchers to dust off their study, which they are updating now. But with domestic flights running 85 to 90 percent full, meaning that virtually all planes on desirable routes are full, Cynthia Barnhart, an M.I.T. professor who studies transportation systems, has a pretty good idea of what the new research will show when it is completed this fall: “There will be severe increases in delays,” she said.


            Meanwhile, Joe Sharkey, who writes the “On the Road” column in the Times, describes widespread reports of passengers sitting for as long as 10 hours on delayed planes with nothing to eat or drink. In some cases, toilets backed up. Sharkey comments,


            At the heart of the problem is the fact that airlines have squeezed their capacity and their work force so much that there is not an inch of slack when something goes wrong, including bad weather.


For several years, some airlines have been reducing their unionized maintenance work force and outsourcing routine maintenance, while passengers have been complaining that aircraft cabins are dirty.


With some justification, the airlines blame the Federal Aviation Administration for not upgrading the air traffic control system to handle current demand adequately.


But a growing number of people are directing their anger at the airlines and demanding federal legislation — a so-called passenger bill of rights — that will make the airlines adhere to specific rules on how long passengers can be held on a parked plane, and impose regulations to address cabin ventilation and public health issues like overflowing toilets.


            Variation in flight schedules is, to some extent, inevitable due to weather delays. So how can the airlines deal with that variation without building in costly buffers that make profits impossible?


            I’m not sure what the answer is. But if someone can come up with a practical, lean approach to these problems, I’d love to hear about. Better yet, if you’d like to write a book on this subject, we’d love to talk to you.


 

7.04.2007

Ross Robson Interview, Part 2: The Need for Fair Trade

Add Ross Robson to the list business leaders who believe that government action is needed to ensure fair trade for American manufacturers.


            Ross, who is retiring as executive director of the Shingo Prize, had some strong words for the federal government when I spoke with him recently.


            “President Bush, in free trade policies for six or seven years, has done nothing to ensure it’s a level playing field. Congress has done very little,” he said. “The issue of fair trade vs. free trade is critical to the success of manufacturing in the U.S. The current administration has basically been blind to the issue of fair trade.”


            Ross was referring specifically to alleged undervaluation of the yuan, the currency of China. Based on estimates from a variety of sources, he believes the yuan may be undervalued by anywhere from 25 percent to 50 percent.


            “The issue of fair trade showed up rather clearly in the congressional elections. All newly elected or re-elected Democrats had campaigned for fair trade, not just free trade,” he said. “We’ve clearly got to right-size that global marketplace and ensure free trade around the world. I see nothing in the horizon suggesting that’s going to occur in the next few months.”


            On its face, fair trade may not sound like a lean issue. However, my impression is that most lean advocates are almost inherently supporters of free trade. We argue that you don’t need to outsource materials or production to compete with low-wage foreign producers; that you can compete successfully in a global marketplace if a lean strategy drives your operations.


            That becomes more challenging when the marketplace is distorted by undervaluation of currencies and/or government subsidies of foreign businesses. So if we want people to truly see what lean can do, we need the level playing field that comes from fair trade.


 

7.02.2007

Ross Robson Interview, Part I: The Obstacles to Lean Implementations

American manufacturers can compete successfully in the global marketplace with lean strategies, but first they have to overcome the obstacle of big egos.


            That’s the sense I get talking with Ross Robson, who is retiring as executive director of the Shingo Prize for Excellence in Manufacturing.


            Ross has always been a passionate advocate of lean manufacturing, and he has been with the Shingo Prize since its inception 19 years ago. A Ph.D., he is also on the faculty of the College of Business of Utah State University, where the Shingo Prize has its headquarters.


            His retirement was announced about a month ago. He will continue working with the Shingo Prize until next spring as director of its public sector prize, developing a partnership with the Department of Defense. He will also retire from the University in September of 2008.


            I recently spent some time on the phone with Ross. Because of his long involvement in lean issues – the Shingo Prize criteria closely parallel Toyota’s principles – I believe he is well-positioned to talk about the state of American manufacturing.


            “My sense is that probably 50 to 60 percent, and maybe as high as 75 percent, of manufacturing companies in North America today are focused on elements of lean manufacturing, lean enterprise,” he told me. “But I would tend to say that at best, five to no more than 10 percent are really doing well at lean. The opportunities remain huge in the U.S. and North America relative to the ‘true north’ implementation of lean enterprise.”


            When I asked him what the chief obstacles are to a broader adoption of true lean principles, Ross didn’t actually use the word ‘ego.’ But he did mention three obstacles, all of which relate to that concept.


            “One of the obstacles is simply new ownership,” he said. “In the world model, not the Toyota model, of leadership, new leaders feel a sense of obligation to come in and leave their mark, and demonstrate that they are in charge. And that model is one of the worst, and one of the biggest challenges to continuous improvement in a company or a business that exists in the marketplace today. It tends to be based on what David Mann in his book calls ‘person-centered leadership’ rather than process-centered leadership.”


            A second issue, Ross contends, is that “particularly in the U.S., we suffer from what I refer to as arrogance, which is the antithesis of good continuous improvement. In other words, we say to ourselves, ‘gee, we’re the richest, most powerful country in the world. Why do we need to, or have to, change?’” He contrasts that with attitudes in Mexico; “I have said for years that if you to to Mexico and say ‘have you thought about…?’ in three months, it’s done. In the U.S., if you say ‘have you thought about…?’ in six years they are still talking about it.”


            The third issue is “the notion that falls into the good old management discussion of power vs. influence. Senior leaders, once they get into a position of authority, don’t want to give up power,” he commented. That’s a problem when it comes to a lean strategy, which involves empowering workers.


            Outside of the Shingo Prize, Ross said his work with students at Utah State has been very rewarding, though he adds that “probably my greatest frustration has been the failure to get students to focus on manufacturing as their career.”


            Despite the ego obstacles and the difficulty finding qualified people, Ross remains optimistic about the future of American manufacturing. However, he also has some strong beliefs about the need for government action in the world marketplace, which I will describe in my next posting.